Some Prevention Efforts Can Actually Backfire

Some prevention campaigns aimed at stopping young drinkers from risky drinking habits can actually backfire if not worded properly. Campaigns designed to stop young people "bolting" drinks can be ineffective and can even make them more likely to do it, new research suggests.

Scientists from the University of Exeter and the University of Queensland examined reactions to a poster warning of the consequences of bolting (downing an alcoholic drink in one) and found it had no effect on people's future intentions.

Correcting Misperceptions

And when a statement was added saying other people disapproved of bolting, study participants reported stronger intentions to bolt in the future.

However, changing this to a message saying most people "do not bolt drinks on a night out" was effective.

"Many young people overestimate the extent to which their peers both approve of and engage in risky drinking behaviors," said study author Dr. Joanne Smith, of the University of Exeter.

"One way to tackle risky drinking is to try to correct these misperceptions through health campaigns, such as posters.

Some Messages More Effective

"In our research, we wanted to explore what kinds of messages are more effective in changing people's intentions to bolt.

"Our results highlight the potentially harmful effects of exposure to what's called an 'injunctive norm' - a message about the approval or disapproval of others.

"Meanwhile, a 'descriptive norm' - telling people what others do rather than what they think - had a positive impact."

The study is published in the journal Addiction Research and Theory.

Poorly Designed Campaigns Can Backfire

Professor Charles Abraham, of the University of Exeter Medical School, said: "This demonstrates how careful we need to be in selecting the right message in campaigns, and evaluating them before wider dissemination, as poorly designed campaigns, however well-intentioned, can backfire."

The research consisted of three studies, in which volunteers (221 in total) saw the poster or did not, and then either received or did not receive messages about what their peers thought or how they behaved.

In one study, some participants received an accurate message saying 70% of their peers "disapprove of bolting", and in another, some received an accurate message saying 65% of their peers "do not bolt drinks on a night out."

Drinking Responsibly

They all then completed identical questionnaires to measure their perceptions of group norms related to bolting, and their own intentions to do it in the future.

The researchers point out that beliefs about how other people behave are often the "best predictor" in terms of general drinking behavior and binge drinking, but note that using these beliefs to change behavior needs to be done carefully to ensure campaigns have the desired effect.

The paper is entitled: "Normative feedback in alcohol-related health promotion: When and how does normative feedback reduce intentions to drink irresponsibly?"

Early Brain Injury Linked to Alcoholism

Researchers at Ohio State University have surveyed previous studies to investigate the relationship between traumatic brain injuries and alcohol abuse. They found evidence that traumatic brain injuries in children and adolescents could be a risk-factor for alcohol abuse in later life.

Continue reading

Strong Policies Lower Drunk Driving Deaths

Stronger alcohol policies protect young people from dying in crashes caused by drunk driving according to researchers at Boston Medical Center. The study, which is published online in the journal Pediatrics, supports the importance of comprehensive alcohol control policies to reduce the number of young people who die in alcohol-related crashes.

Continue reading

Ignition Interlock Devices Reduce Fatal Crashes

State laws requiring ignition interlocks for all drunk driving offenders appear to reduce the number of fatal drunk driving crashes, a new study by Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health and Colorado School of Public Health researchers suggests.

Continue reading

Late Teen Drinking Can Lead to Liver Problems

Alcohol is the leading cause of liver cirrhosis and liver-related deaths. Results of a large long-term study in Sweden have confirmed that drinking during late adolescence could be the first step towards liver problems in adulthood and that guidelines for safe alcohol intake in men might have to be revised downwards, reports the Journal of Hepatology.

Continue reading

Teen Binge Drinking Affects Cognitive Skills

Drinking alcohol, is a well-engrained and long-standing social habit in many countries around the world, even though the fact that alcohol has an impact on one's health is largely established, especially when it comes to heavy drinking.

Continue reading

Alcohol-Related Mortality Rates Have Doubled

Alcohol-related deaths have increased dramatically in the past two decades, with mortality rates almost doubling since 1999. The highest rates of alcohol-related deaths occurred in the 55 to 64 age group, but the biggest rate increase occurred within the 25 to 34 age group. In the United States and  […]

Continue reading

Trusting Counselor Vital to Treatment Success

A positive, trusting relationship between counselor and patient, known as a "therapeutic alliance," can be key to successful treatment of alcohol use disorder, a study finds. Gerard Connors, PhD, senior research scientist at the University at Buffalo Research Institute on Addictions, studied more than five dozen people engaging in a 12-week program of cognitive behavior therapy for alcohol use disorder.

Continue reading

Alcohol's Health Benefits Overstated?

The benefits of light alcohol consumption, as well as the risks associated with not drinking at all, might not be as great as previously thought, according to Penn State researchers who examined the drinking habits of middle-aged adults.

Continue reading

Binge Drinking Quickly Leads to Liver Disease

Alcohol consumed during just seven weeks of intermittent binge drinking harms the liver in ways that more moderate daily drinking does not, according to researchers at UC San Francisco. The scientists discovered that just 21 binge drinking sessions were enough to cause symptoms of early-stage liver disease.

Continue reading

Alcohol Increases Risks of Heart Conditions

Alcohol abuse increases the risk of atrial fibrillation, heart attack and congestive heart failure as much as other well-established risk factors such as high blood pressure, diabetes, smoking and obesity, according to a study published in the Journal of the American College of Cardiology.

Continue reading


Page top